The Best Thrift Stores in Madison, Wisconsin

Madison, known for its collegiate atmosphere and community-oriented spirit, offers a thriving thrift store scene that caters to students, locals, and environmentally conscious shoppers alike. From quaint vintage shops to larger second-hand stores, Madison provides a variety of options for those seeking unique finds and sustainable fashion.

Vintage Clothing and Accessories

St. Vincent de Paul

St. Vincent de Paul
Marc Banks

Location: 1309 Williamson St, Madison

Vibe: Community-focused, treasure-filled

St. Vincent de Paul is not just a thrift store but a community institution in Madison. It offers a wide range of items from clothing to household goods, with a particularly strong selection of vintage clothing. The store is known for its affordable prices and the friendly atmosphere cultivated by both staff and regular shoppers.

Good Style Shop

Good Style Shop
Good Style Shop

Location: 402 E Wilson St, Madison

Vibe: Hip, curated

Specializing in vintage from the 60s to the 90s, Good Style Shop is a favorite among local fashion enthusiasts and students. The store offers a well-curated selection of vintage clothing and accessories, providing stylish yet affordable options for those looking to add some retro flair to their wardrobe.

Designer Second-Hand

ReThreads

ReThreads
ReThreads

Location: 410 State St, Madison

Vibe: Chic, upscale

Situated in the bustling State Street area, ReThreads features a range of high-end second-hand clothing and accessories. The store prides itself on its selection of designer labels at significantly reduced prices, making luxury fashion accessible to a broader audience.

Unique Finds and Specialty Shops

Hive of Madison

Hive of Madison
Hive of Madison

Location: 1904 Monroe St, Madison

Vibe: Outdoorsy, sustainable

Hive of Madison is known for its selection of high-quality outdoor gear and clothing. It’s the go-to place for adventurers looking for second-hand hiking boots, backpacks, and apparel. The store supports sustainability in fashion with a focus on durable brands and functional styles.

Agrace Thrift Store

Agrace Thrift Store
Agrace Thrift Store

Location: 118 Junction Rd, Madison

Vibe: Eclectic, community-serving

Agrace Thrift Store offers a wide variety of items from clothing to furniture, all donated by the community. Profits from the store support the local Agrace Hospice & Palliative Care, making each purchase a contribution to an important cause.

Contemporary Second-Hand and Streetwear

Plato’s Closet

Plato’s Closet
Fred Schulze

Location: 7858 Mineral Point Rd, Madison

Vibe: Trendy, youthful

Plato’s Closet in Madison caters to a younger crowd, offering contemporary second-hand clothing and accessories that follow the latest fashion trends. The store is perfect for college students and young professionals looking for affordable, stylish outfits.

UpShift

UpShift
UpShift

Location: 836 E Johnson St, Madison

Vibe: Modern, fashionable

UpShift specializes in swapping and selling contemporary fashion. With a focus on sustainability, the store encourages Madison’s fashion-savvy individuals to rethink their consumption habits by offering a stylish and eco-friendly alternative to fast fashion.

Markets and Flea Markets

East Side Flea Market

East Side Flea Market
East Side Flea Market

Location: 2044 Atwood Ave, Madison

Vibe: Vintage, artsy

The East Side Flea Market is a local favorite, known for its vibrant atmosphere and diverse array of vendors. Shoppers can find everything from vintage clothing and handmade jewelry to antique furniture and collectibles. It’s a great place to spend a weekend morning browsing and discovering unique items.

Madison Night Market

Madison Night Market
Madison Night Market

Location: State Street & Gilman St, Madison

Vibe: Lively, festive

The Madison Night Market showcases local artisans, craftsmen, and thrift vendors. It provides a festive shopping experience with live music, food stalls, and a wide variety of goods, making it a perfect evening outing for families and young adults alike.