New Haven has a thriving second-hand shopping scene that blends curated vintage fashion, thrift store bargains, and unique specialty shops.
Whether you’re searching for one-of-a-kind clothing, used books, or affordable furniture, this guide will help you navigate the city’s best thrift and vintage stores.
Savers
Location: 130 Boston Post Rd, Orange, CT
Website: savers.com
Phone: (203) 891-0789
Vibe: Budget-friendly, large selection
Savers is a go-to spot for affordable clothing, home goods, and accessories. Known for its organized layout and frequent sales, this thrift store attracts shoppers looking for bargains. The store also supports nonprofit organizations through donations, making it a great place to shop while giving back.
Goodwill Westville Store and Donation Center
Location: 61 Amity Rd # 4, New Haven, CT
Website: goodwillsne.org
Phone: (203) 397-2735
Vibe: Community-driven, sustainable shopping
This Goodwill location provides everything from second-hand fashion to home furnishings at competitive prices. Proceeds from sales fund job training programs and employment opportunities, making it a thrift store with a mission.
Witch Bitch Thrift
Location: 105 Whitney Ave, New Haven, CT
Website: witchbitchthrift.com
Phone: (203) 553-5703
Vibe: Alternative, quirky
Witch Bitch Thrift is a unique shop that blends vintage fashion with a mystical aesthetic. Specializing in alternative clothing, handmade jewelry, and oddities, this store is perfect for shoppers looking for something outside the mainstream.
Noir Vintage & Company
Location: 111 Court St, New Haven, CT
Vibe: Stylish, well-curated
Noir Vintage & Company offers a mix of vintage clothing and accessories. The boutique-style layout makes for an enjoyable browsing experience, and the store’s collection is carefully curated for those who appreciate high-quality vintage pieces.
Soulful Threads
Location: 1022 Chapel St, New Haven, CT
Website: shopsoulfulthreads.com
Vibe: Vintage, fashionable
A hidden gem in the vintage fashion scene, Soulful Threads specializes in unique second-hand clothing, accessories, and home décor. The shop frequently updates its inventory with stylish pieces that appeal to both casual shoppers and collectors.
Vintanthro Modern & Vintage
Location: 895 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT
Website: vintanthromodern.com
Phone: (484) 816-8243
Vibe: Trendy, curated
For those who appreciate vintage style but want a modern twist, Vintanthro offers a mix of contemporary and retro fashion. The shop is known for its carefully curated selection and excellent customer service.
Lower Forms
Location: 16 Fountain St, New Haven, CT
Vibe: Edgy, minimalist
Lower Forms specializes in vintage streetwear and contemporary fashion. With a mix of rare pieces and upcycled clothing, this store is popular among trendsetters looking for something unique.
Fashionista Vintage & Variety
Location: 85 Willow St Bldg. #1, New Haven, CT
Phone: (475) 355-3358
Vibe: Eclectic, fun
Fashionista Vintage & Variety is packed with colorful clothing, accessories, and vintage treasures. The store has a vibrant atmosphere, and shoppers can find everything from retro dresses to funky statement pieces.
Strange Ways
Location: 151 Orange St, New Haven, CT
Website: strange-ways.com
Phone: (203) 772-8371
Vibe: Indie, artistic
This fashion accessories shop is a favorite among creatives, offering an array of pins, patches, and unique apparel. Strange Ways is a must-visit for those who want to add a little personality to their wardrobe.
Softwear New Haven
Location: 742 Chapel St, New Haven, CT
Website: Instagram
Vibe: Retro, sustainable
Softwear New Haven focuses on sustainable fashion and vintage streetwear. Shoppers looking for well-curated, eco-friendly fashion will enjoy browsing through the carefully selected inventory.
Grey Matter Books
Location: 264 York St, New Haven, CT
Website: greymatterbookstore.com
Phone: (203) 553-3180
Vibe: Cozy, intellectual
A must-visit for book lovers, Grey Matter Books specializes in used and rare books. With a welcoming atmosphere and a well-organized selection, this store is perfect for collectors and casual readers alike.