Indianapolis, with its growing reputation for diverse shopping experiences, hosts a variety of thrift stores that cater to those looking for sustainable fashion, unique finds, and vintage treasures.
Vintage Clothing and Accessories
Broad Ripple Vintage
Location: 824 E 64th St, Indianapolis
Vibe: Retro, eclectic
Nestled in the heart of Broad Ripple, this store is a treasure trove of vintage clothing, offering everything from 1960s mod dresses to 1980s glam rock jackets. It’s a vibrant spot for fashion enthusiasts looking to make a statement with unique, one-of-a-kind pieces.
Naptown Thrift
Location: 2174 E 54th St, Indianapolis
Vibe: Hip, nostalgic
Specializing in vintage sportswear and streetwear, Naptown Thrift is a haven for 80s and 90s fashion lovers. Its curated selection includes rare finds from brands like Nike, Adidas, and Tommy Hilfiger, attracting both collectors and trendy shoppers.
Designer Second-Hand
The Toggery Resale Boutique
Location: 1810 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis
Vibe: Upscale, chic
The Toggery Resale Boutique is known for its selection of high-end designer clothing and accessories at consignment prices. From contemporary labels to luxury brands, it offers an elegant shopping experience for those looking to add sophisticated pieces to their wardrobe without the designer price tag.
Simply Chic
Location: 8435 Ditch Rd, Indianapolis(Permanently closed)
Vibe: Modern, fashionable
Simply Chic focuses on providing a selection of gently used women’s fashion, including designer brands and current trends. The store is meticulously organized, making it easy for shoppers to find high-quality items and everyday wear.
Unique Finds and Specialty Shops
Society of Salvage
Location: 1021 E Michigan St, Indianapolis
Vibe: Industrial, eclectic
Society of Salvage is an off-the-beaten-path destination for those interested in industrial salvage and unique vintage finds. From vintage office supplies to mid-century furniture, it offers an intriguing assortment for decorators and collectors alike.
Indy Artsy
Location: 1125 E Brookside Ave, Indianapolis(Permanently closed)
Vibe: Artistic, local
Located in the Circle City Industrial Complex, Indy Artsy is a boutique showcasing local artists and artisans. It offers a selection of handmade goods, vintage finds, and repurposed items, supporting the local creative community.
Contemporary Second-Hand and Streetwear
Plato’s Closet
Location: Multiple locations, including 8928 US 31 S, Indianapolis
Vibe: Youthful, trendy
Plato’s Closet is popular among teens and young adults for its affordable selection of contemporary second-hand clothing and accessories. The store buys and sells current fashion trends, making it a great place for those looking to refresh their wardrobe on a budget.
Rag-O-Rama
Location: 1065 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis(Permanently closed)
Vibe: Funky, diverse
Rag-O-Rama offers a wide range of second-hand clothing, from vintage pieces to modern apparel. Its lively atmosphere and diverse selection cater to a broad audience, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Markets and Flea Markets
The Irvington Flea Market
Location: 6301 E Washington St, Indianapolis
Vibe: Bustling, varied
A staple in the community, The Irvington Flea Market is home to numerous vendors selling antiques, collectibles, and second-hand goods. It’s a lively spot to find everything from vintage jewelry to used books and records.
Midland Arts & Antiques Market
Location: 907 E Michigan St, Indianapolis
Vibe: Bohemian, antique
Known for its vast selection of antiques, art, and vintage items, Midland Arts & Antiques Market is a favorite among decorators and collectors. The market offers an eclectic mix of goods in a warehouse setting, providing a unique shopping experience.
Indianapolis’s thrift scene offers a delightful mix of vintage, designer second-hand, and unique finds, reflecting the city’s diverse and vibrant culture.